Navigate / search

Forthcoming events...

2026

28 November 2026, Marx House, London. Len Crome annual event, with Profs Helen Graham and Paul Preston.

Review of Jo Labayi’s What Have You Done For Victory?

Cover of Jo Labanyi's cultural history of the Spanish Civil War, 'What Have you Done for Victory?'

History, as the aphorism frequently attributed to Churchill would have it, is written by the victors. This certainly holds true for the Bayeux Tapestry, as anyone fortunate enough to have seen it recently in London will have seen. However, there are of course exceptions, one of the most glaring examples being the Spanish Civil War of 1936-1939. If British audiences know anything about the conflict at all, they will have likely come to it via supporters of the defeated Republicans such as George Orwell or Ernest Hemingway or having seen Ken Loach’s ‘story from the Spanish revolution’, Land and Freedom. As the German historian Reinhart Koelleck points out: ‘while the victors impose their view of the past in the short term, it is the defeated who advance historical knowledge because they are forced to ask why they lost.’ Or, as the philosopher Miguel de Unamuno dismissively informed General Millán-Astray, the brutal commander of the Spanish Legion during the civil war, ‘venceréis, pero no convenceréis’ (you will win, but you won’t convince) …

My review of Jo Labanyi’s cultural history of the Spanish Civil War appears in The Spectator.

Giles Tremlett’s The International Brigades: Fascism, Freedom and the Spanish Civil War.

On 12 November, 2020 I joined Giles for an online discussion and virtual launch of Giles Tremlett‘s new study of the International Brigades, hosted by the IBMT and Marx Memorial Library. You can listen to the discussion here.

My review of the book appears in the latest edition of The Spectator. I thought it an engaging read and a well-researched, comprehensive work of scholarship. Based on a mass of primary research, especially the RGASPI material in Moscow, he’s written a very even-handed, ‘warts and all’ account. And his conclusion is, I think a fair one:

‘There was nothing perfect about the brigaders and attempts to paint them as 20th century saints only serve to highlight their failings. These were (mostly) men at war. They killed and were killed. Some fought bravely, others did not. Some were noble and brave in their actions, others were cruel, cowardly or callous. Some fought for an ideal, others for adventure. And, for some, those ideals would take them on a journey of oppression that placed them closer, in their behaviour and blind defence of Stalinist communism, to the fascists whom they declared as their enemies than to the democratic Republic that they defended. All fought, however, against the most destructive and evil force unleashed by 20th century Europe’s violent politics and history. As Bernard Knox – by then a distinguished Classics professor at Yale – pointed out, there could be nothing ‘premature’ about anti-fascism.’

Giles Tremlett, The International Brigades: Fascism, Freedom and the Spanish Civil War. London: Bloomsbury, 2020, p. 528.

  • cv

    Curriculum Vitae

    Download a pdf of Richard's CV More

  • networking

    Linked in

    Contact Richard via Linked In, the business networking site More

  • attibutes

    Research

    Current areas of research and forthcoming projects More